
I recently got a chuckle out of all the advice that was dispensed, after someone who was headed to Nashville asked the question on Linkedin, “Can someone recommend a local Recruiter?”
Over a period of three months, at least 45 people weighed in with dozens of different recommendations and, amazingly, most people never even considered the occupation the inquisitor was even pursuing. They simply rattled off the names of recruiters, staffing firms, talent sourcing firms, contingency recruitment firms and retained search firms – across dozens of different specialties.
I didn’t see a bad recruiter mentioned by anyone – and several great ones were left out – but the outcome was, that most of the firms or recruiters mentioned didn’t make placements in her career field.
My point: Asking someone to recommend a local recruiter is akin to asking someone to recommend a local doctor.
In an ironic twist, as I was writing this post, the very person who asked this question on LinkedIn contacted me to seek our representation.
I talked to her about the overwhelming diversity of recommendations she received on Linkedin, and was prepared to caution her with one of my favorite sayings, “Prescription before diagnosis is Malpractice.” However, my advice wasn’t needed – she was clearly a smart candidate. Before I could say anything, she quickly acknowledged that while she sincerely appreciated everyone’s effort to help over the past three months, she had discovered that most of the firms and recruiters who were recommended weren’t really a fit for her own personal situation – or that of her husband.
WHAT IS YOUR CAREER FOCUS?
If you had nagging knee pain, would you seek the help of an OB/GYN practice, because your friend said they had the very best doctors?
At a recent soccer game I attended, I overheard a parent – cheering for the opposing team – recommend a local recruiter, who they mentioned was a “good friend”, to a fellow parent who was looking for a permanent Staff Accounting job. I had to wince, as I knew that, while the recruiter she was recommending was a fantastic recruiter, they specialized in Plastics Engineering. Apparently, as far as she was concerned – a recruiter is a recruiter.
Well, it isn’t that simple. Most permanent hire (only) recruiters – what most call “headhunters” – are specialist in a particular industry or vocational category. Therefore, you are completely wasting your time sending your resume to many headhunting firms. They are entirely focused on a very narrow sector, and they don’t have time even to call or write to tell you that you’re barking up the wrong tree.
WHAT IS YOUR CURRENT CIRCUMSTANCE?
It isn’t just about recruiter specialty; it can also be a matter of your immediate circumstance. For instance, if your leg were broken in an auto accident, would you go to the nearest emergency room – or schedule an appointment for the following week, with an Orthopedic Surgeon?
Case in point. You’ll see several excellent administrative staffing firms within retail shopping centers throughout Nashville. If you are unemployed and have impressive Microsoft Office skills, and need immediate employment – doing anything, anywhere, for anyone – you would be foolish not to go see them for a temporary or interim opportunity.
However, if you’re a frustrated, but employed, Director of Content Management, and methodically looking for a more senior-level content management position, there are far more appropriate solutions within the spectrum of human capital companies.
WHERE DO YOU LIVE (OR WANT TO LIVE)
What if your next-door neighbor convinced you that the best Pediatrician was in San Diego, but you live in Nashville? Of course, you want the very best for your child, but is this really a practical choice?
I hate to be the one to burst the proverbial bubble, but the average executive-level, permanent-placement specialty headhunter makes about six placements in an entire year – and rarely are any of their job opportunities (or candidates) within a couple of hundred miles of their office. Does this mean they aren’t good at what they do – of course not! In fact, Nashville is blessed with some of the best specialty recruiters you’ll find in the U.S..
My point: If you are looking for a headhunter to assist you with a permanent, full-time executive position in Nashville – possibly outside of IT and Accounting – your recruiter options are far more limited.
YOU DON’T HAVE TO MARRY YOUR RECRUITER
The wonderful difference between the medical profession and the recruiting profession is that recruiters don’t charge candidates for their services. Their only paying client is the employer. Therefore, use as many recruiters as you wish. Just make sure they are practical for your career choice and circumstance.
Granted, most recruitment firms would prefer that you use them exclusively – and a handful will even go so far as to suggest that it is unwise to use more than one. However, the simple truth is that this is self-serving advice, on their part.
Recruiters should always be professional and courteous to candidates – but don’t ever forget that they see you as perishable inventory. Remember, you are a “free agent” – so act like one. No matter how much the recruiter seems to like you – and truly wants to help – don’t think that they wake up in the middle of the night, asking themselves, “How am I going to get good ol’ John a job?”. Instead, they are asking themselves, “Where are we going to find the right candidates for the position at XYZ Company?”.
Recruiters aren’t magic job fairies. They can’t create demand for positions – only the market can do that. And at the end of the day, only a fraction of candidates – represented by even the most successful recruiting firms – get jobs as a result of a recruiter. Ultimately, you will always be your #1 agent.
At the end of the day, you are leading the sales effort for the product called “YOU”, so don’t depend solely on a recruiter for your success, nor blame a recruiter – for your lack of it.
AUTHOR: Mark Newsom
Founder of FiveChairs, a Recruitment Firm, focused on Nashville Talent | mark.newsom@fivechairs.com

Invite Me. I’ll Accept.